By Hakan Okçal
This article initially focused on the government’s climate policy contradictions at the COP31 Antalya Summit. However, a police raid against the popular SZC TV channel compelled me to dwell first on President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s hardening repression of independent journalism and freedom of expression.
SZC TV has been put under trusteeship, like Halk TV before it, and was one of the last remaining vestiges of independent media that dared to air unbiased news and different opinions, although they irritated the government.
The raid was ordered ostensibly on the grounds of an old investigation for dubious “financing of terrorism” charges against its owner, not the channel itself. However, Erdoğan’s ally Devlet Bahçeli, chair of the ultra-rightist MHP, gave the real reason when he accused the managers of the channel and participants in its programs – of which I was one – of acting and speaking “liberally” against the government.
SZC TV was silenced during COP31, when the international media was still reporting from Turkey. Apparently, he could not even wait a few days until the end of the conference in the face of mounting criticism against his regime over the fund scandal. Even this daring act showcases Erdoğan’s desperation to silence opposition and hold on to power whatever the consequences.
MISSING AT COP31
Erdoğan’s goal in hosting COP31 was to portray himself as a respected world leader and to greenwash his much criticized environmental policies in an attempt to lay the ground for yet another mandate. He spent more than $500 million on COP31, although Turkey needs every penny in a self-inflicted financial crisis.
Whether he has achieved his goal is questionable. The pro-government mouthpieces that make up almost the entirety of the mass media, especially after the silencing of Halk TV and SZC TV, tried to project an upbeat picture from Antalya focusing on trivialities such as the lavish display of Turkish hospitality and the “seamless organization” of the summit.
They also turned the limelight on Haydar Aliyev who flew in for a short stay after a crisis between the two countries about headscarves and Turkish meddling in Azerbaijan’s internal affairs. The shunning of the Cypriot Greek leader Christodoulides by Erdoğan and criticism levelled against Israel and Benjamin Netanyahu were also played up by pro-government media.
However, these were not enough to portray Erdoğan as a popular world leader. In fact, the majority of leaders avoided COP31 for one reason or another. None of the Europeans, barring Finnish President Alexander Stubb, were present in Antalya. Similarly, all the G7 leaders apart from UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham stayed away. No one was expecting Donald Trump, but China’s Xi Jinping, Russia’s Vladimir Putin, Japan’s Sanae Takaichi and India’s Narendra Modi were also missing. The only prominent leader in Antalya was the previous host, Brazil’s Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva. World leaders preferred the European Political Community, ASEAN and APEC summits respectively in Dublin, Manila and Shenzhen.
GOALS VERSUS REALITY
Turkey’s enthusiasm to host the UN climate summit came as a surprise. Because, until COP31, the government’s contributions to world climate efforts can only be described as minimal, if not negative. Nevertheless, Turkey has declared a zero emission goal by 2053, although there is no credible roadmap. Turkey still depends on fossil energy for most of its energy, although there have been some positive steps towards wind and solar energy.
However, Turkey still issues licences for brown coal mining on olive groves and forests. Mining of gold and other minerals damages the environment. Construction of small dams on streams has destroyed scarce water supplies. The seas surrounding Turkey, as well as its lakes and rivers, have been polluted by industrial and sewage discharges. These are but a few examples of environmental misdeeds. On top of these human-made disasters, Turkey suffers more than many around the Mediterranean from wildfires, flooding, and desertification due to climate change.
Ankara’s priority in the summit was the so-called “Zero Waste” goal, a project launched in 2017 under Emine Erdoğan’s patronage. However, the import of around 700 thousand tons of plastic waste from Europe, which has heavily polluted the environment in and around the fertile Çukurova agricultural region in southern Turkey takes any credibility for such a noble aim. Before leading a global “Zero Waste” initiative, Turkey must clean up its own act.
Turkey has also launched a global electrification initiative under the “35x35” banner, meaning to raise electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035. Here again, Turkey must achieve a lot in its own electrification to lead such an ambitious initiative. Until its fossil energy dependence is ended, there is no reason for credibility.
A reliable climate struggle can only be waged if there are basic civil rights and freedoms in a country. Living in a safe and clean environment is part of basic civil rights and freedoms after all. If Turkey wants to have a respectable place in the global world community it must first let democracy and civil liberties function.
* Hakan Okçal is a retired Turkish ambassador. He joined the Foreign Ministry in 1978 and served in various diplomatic posts, including NATO, Bonn, Berlin, and as Consul General in Komotini. He was Turkey's Ambassador to Abuja, to Skopje, and later to Seoul. After retiring in 2018, he lectured on diplomacy at universities for five years and is currently a member of the Ankara Policy Center (APM).