By Barçın Yinanç
The Mecca joint defense pact with Saudi Arabia and Pakistan took effect on Nov. 14, following its publication in the Official Gazette. The agreement was signed on Aug. 7, a few weeks after the civil war resumed in Yemen, as Iran-backed Houthis stepped up their attacks.
Asked on Aug. 8 whether the agreement’s provision treating an attack on one signatory as an attack on all was equivalent to NATO’s Article 5, Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan replied, “technically, the same.”
Fidan’s comparison with NATO raised expectations about the three countries' commitments. He later tried to dismiss criticism about the deterrent force of the pact, which was challenged immediately by Houthi forces, by saying that NATO’s Article 5 was invoked only once in 77 years of the alliance. “But they’re pointing to a 10-year-old crisis in Yemen to argue that a newly established defense alliance isn’t working. We’ve only just started,” he said in September.
NATO’s Article 5 has been invoked only once, precisely because its deterrent effect has largely worked. By contrast, the credibility of the Mecca Pact was undermined from the outset: when Houthi attacks began targeting strategic sites inside Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Turkey did not treat them as attacks against themselves under the pact.
There is a lack of clarity regarding what constitutes an attack and how threats are defined, according to a report published by TEPAV, the Economic Policy Research Foundation of Turkey. Moreover, according to the authors, the nature and scope of the assistance to be provided in the event of an attack remain insufficiently defined.
The key criticism of the pact is the absence of a common threat perception, since the three countries live in distinct geographies, with different security environments and different threat perceptions.
THE RISKS FOR COUNTER EFFECTS
No doubt, what Ankara intends is to create a security framework in the Middle East to fill the gap left by the expected US retrenchment from the region.
The new initiative is explained by “regional ownership.” While presented as such, this concept is not a magical formula found by the ruling AKP; at different times, successive governments tried different ways of finding regional solutions to regional problems. As usual, what differs the AKP from its predecessors is its highly ambitious implementation of past concepts.
If the intention is to boost confidence among regional players and thus prevent conflict, Ankara could have proposed the establishment of a “security organization,” like the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), as suggested by Sinan Ülgen, the director of the Centre for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies (EDAM).
The current Mecca defense pact, however, risks creating a counter effect.
The alliances “risk making Turkey and the region less secure, not more. The Mecca pact with Pakistan and Saudi Arabia could end up hardening rival blocs and elevating regional tensions,” wrote professor Meliha Behli Altunışık from Middle East Technical University.
Turkey insists that the alliance is directed against no country in particular. “But in the meantime, Iran, Israel, and the Houthis could see it as a threat and try to test or weaken its members’ commitment,” Altunışık added in her article titled “The Fantasy of Turkish Middle East.”
It’s also clear that Ankara opted for a defense pact in order to increase its military sales to both countries and obtain the financing it needs to boost its defense industry.
MEETING IN ISTANBUL
Meanwhile, two developments took place, helping Turkey to convey the message that it does not see the Mecca defense pact as simply a military organisation.
The R4 (Egypt joining the Mecca signatories) and E3 (Germany, France, UK, plus Italy) meeting in Istanbul on Oct. 23 provided a diplomatic platform to convey the message to discourage the US and Israel from fresh attacks against Iran, which were expected at that time due to elections in both countries.
This was followed by the visit of a high-level delegation from the countries of the Mecca Agreement to Tehran on Oct. 26. The visit to Tehran was important in conveying the message that the alliance did not pose a threat to Iran.
Despite Ankara’s stated aims of establishing a security framework in the region precisely to avoid wars, the risk of Turkey being entangled in conflict remains high since Saudi Arabia is said to have asked for concrete military assistance.